What Leo Tolstoy Can Teach Us About Customer Segmentation for Brand Success

Shah Mohammed
19 min readMay 14, 2024

Leo Tolstoy, the renowned Russian author, is best known for his epic novels such as “War and Peace” and “Anna Karenina.” However, his literary genius extends far beyond these masterpieces. Tolstoy’s keen observations of human nature and his ability to capture the essence of different personality types are evident throughout his works. Interestingly, these insights are not limited to the realm of literature; they can also be applied to modern business and branding. In one of his lesser-known short stories, Tolstoy presents a categorization of soldiers that can serve as a framework for customer segmentation. By understanding and adapting Tolstoy’s categorization to customer segmentation, brands can create targeted strategies for success.

Tolstoy’s Soldier Categorization

In the short story, Tolstoy divides soldiers into three main categories: Obedient, Domineering or Dictatorial, and Desperate. He further subdivides each category to provide a more nuanced understanding of the soldiers’ characteristics.

The Obedient category is split into Apathetic Obedient and Energetic Obedient. Apathetic Obedient soldiers are those who follow orders without much enthusiasm or personal investment. They may perform their duties adequately, but they lack the drive to go above and beyond. On the other hand, Energetic Obedient soldiers are those who wholeheartedly embrace their roles and carry out their tasks with zeal and dedication.

The Domineering or Dictatorial category is also divided into two subtypes: Gruffly Domineering and Diplomatically Domineering. Gruffly Domineering soldiers are those who assert their authority through aggressive and intimidating means. They may bark orders and demand compliance without considering the opinions or well-being of others. Conversely, Diplomatically Domineering soldiers are those who exercise their influence through persuasion and negotiation. They may be just as determined to achieve their goals, but they do so by engaging others and finding common ground.

Finally, the Desperate category is subdivided into Desperate Jesters and Simply Desperate. Desperate Jesters are soldiers who use humor, wit, or unconventional methods to cope with their circumstances or to gain attention. They may make light of serious situations or engage in mischief to alleviate their desperation. Simply Desperate soldiers, on the other hand, are those who are in dire straits and may resort to extreme measures to survive or achieve their objectives.

Tolstoy’s categorization of soldiers provides a framework for understanding the diverse personalities and motivations that can exist within a group. By recognizing these distinct types, leaders can tailor their approaches to effectively manage and engage with each individual. Similarly, by adapting this framework to customer segmentation, brands can develop targeted strategies to better serve and connect with their audience.

Adapting Tolstoy’s Categories to Customer Segmentation

Tolstoy’s soldier categorization can be seamlessly translated into customer segments, providing brands with a valuable framework for understanding and targeting their audience. By recognizing the distinct characteristics and motivations of each customer type, businesses can develop tailored strategies to better serve and engage with their clientele.

Obedient Customers: The Obedient customers, much like their soldier counterparts, can be divided into two subgroups: loyal but passive customers and enthusiastic, engaged customers.

Loyal but passive customers are those who consistently choose a brand’s products or services but may not actively participate in brand-related activities or discussions. They are satisfied with their experience but are not likely to go out of their way to promote the brand. For example, a grocery store chain like Kroger offers a loyalty program that rewards customers for their continued patronage without requiring much active engagement.

On the other hand, enthusiastic and engaged customers are those who not only regularly purchase from a brand but also actively participate in brand communities, share their positive experiences with others, and are eager to provide feedback and suggestions. Sephora, a beauty retailer, create a vibrant online community where customers can share their experiences, participate in product discussions, and receive exclusive offers. The value proposition focuses on personalized recommendations, expert advice, and a sense of belonging to a passionate community.

Domineering Customers: Domineering customers, similar to Domineering soldiers, can be categorized as either assertive influencers or persuasive negotiators. Assertive influencers are customers who are vocal about their opinions and may try to sway a brand’s decisions or direction through forceful or aggressive means. They may publicly criticize a brand’s actions or demand specific changes without much consideration for the brand’s perspective. These customers are assertive and may provide blunt feedback. Software companies like Microsoft actively seek input from this segment through targeted surveys and forums, acknowledging their concerns and communicating how their feedback is being used to improve products.

Persuasive negotiators, in contrast, are customers who seek to influence a brand’s direction through more diplomatic means. They may engage in constructive dialogue, offer well-reasoned arguments, and work towards finding mutually beneficial solutions. A luxury car brand like Mercedes-Benz engages this segment through exclusive focus groups or advisory boards, where their insights and suggestions are valued and implemented.

Desperate Customers: Desperate customers, akin to Desperate soldiers, can be divided into unconventional attention-seekers and those in dire need. Unconventional attention-seekers are customers who may resort to unusual or provocative methods to gain a brand’s attention or to stand out from the crowd. They may create controversial content, engage in attention-grabbing stunts, or use humour to capture a brand’s interest. Desperate Jester customers could be those customers who use humour to gain attention. A fast-food chain like Wendy’s engages this segment through witty social media interactions, meme-inspired campaigns, or quirky promotional events.

Customers in dire need, on the other hand, are those who have an urgent or critical requirement for a brand’s products or services. They may be facing a crisis situation or have a pressing need that only the brand can address. An insurance company like State Farm provide dedicated support channels and expedited claims processing for customers facing emergency situations.

Value Proposition

By dividing customers into segments based on Tolstoy’s categorization and studying their needs, behaviours, and changing attitudes, brands can significantly improve their value propositions and deliver enhanced benefits to their entire customer base. Let’s explore how this segmentation approach can help brands strengthen their value propositions.

  1. Identifying Common Needs and Pain Points: By analyzing the needs and behaviours of each customer segment, brands can uncover common themes and pain points that resonate across multiple segments. For example, a software company may discover that both Apathetic Obedient and Energetic Obedient customers value ease of use and reliability, while Gruffly Domineering and Diplomatically Domineering customers prioritize customization options and integration capabilities. By identifying these shared needs, the company can craft a value proposition that emphasizes its commitment to delivering user-friendly, dependable software solutions with robust customization and integration features, appealing to a broad range of customers.
  2. Addressing Emotional Drivers: Studying the behaviours and attitudes of Desperate Jesters and Simply Desperate customers can provide insights into the underlying emotional drivers that influence customer decision-making. A healthcare provider, for instance, may discover that these segments value empathy, compassion, and a sense of partnership in their healthcare journey. By incorporating these emotional elements into its value proposition, the provider can highlight its patient-centric approach, emphasizing its dedication to providing not only high-quality medical care but also emotional support and guidance. This emotionally resonant value proposition can attract and retain customers across all segments who seek a healthcare partner who understands and cares for their overall well-being.
  3. Enhancing Product Development and Innovation: Insights gained from Domineering customers can drive product development and innovation efforts that benefit the entire customer base. A consumer electronics brand, for example, may receive valuable feedback from Gruffly Domineering customers regarding desired features, performance improvements, and emerging technologies. By incorporating this feedback into its product roadmap and value proposition, the brand can showcase its commitment to continuous innovation, offering cutting-edge products that meet the evolving needs of all customers. This approach not only satisfies the demands of Domineering customers but also attracts Obedient and Desperate customers who value staying ahead of the technological curve.
  4. Improving Customer Experience and Support: By understanding the unique needs and preferences of each customer segment, brands can enhance their overall customer experience and support offerings. A retail brand, for instance, may learn that Apathetic Obedient customers value quick and efficient transactions, while Energetic Obedient customers appreciate personalized recommendations and engaging in-store experiences. Desperate Jesters, on the other hand, may seek out humorous or unconventional customer service interactions. By tailoring its customer experience and support strategies to cater to these diverse needs, the brand can create a value proposition that emphasizes its commitment to delivering exceptional, segment-specific experiences. This approach can improve customer satisfaction, loyalty, and advocacy across all segments.
  5. Adapting to Changing Attitudes and Preferences: Monitoring changes in attitudes and behaviours within each customer segment enables brands to stay responsive to evolving customer needs and preferences. A financial services firm, for example, may notice a growing interest in sustainable and socially responsible investments among its Diplomatically Domineering customers. By adapting its product offerings and value proposition to highlight its commitment to ethical and environmentally conscious investing, the firm can appeal to a broader range of customers who prioritize aligning their financial goals with their values. This agility in adapting to changing customer attitudes can help the firm maintain its relevance and competitiveness in the market.

By leveraging Tolstoy’s customer segmentation approach, brands can develop value propositions that address the common needs, emotional drivers, and evolving preferences of their diverse customer base. This comprehensive understanding of customer segments allows brands to deliver enhanced products, services, and experiences that resonate with customers across all categories. By continuously refining their value propositions based on insights gained from each segment, brands can establish themselves as customer-centric organizations that prioritize delivering exceptional value to all customers, driving long-term growth and success.

Emotional Branding

Building an emotional brand is crucial for creating deep, lasting connections with customers and fostering long-term loyalty. By leveraging Tolstoy’s customer segmentation approach, brands can gain valuable insights into the emotional needs and motivations of their diverse customer base, enabling them to craft a powerful emotional brand identity that resonates with all segments.

  1. Understanding Emotional Drivers: By studying the behaviours and attitudes of each customer segment, brands can uncover the underlying emotional drivers that influence customer decision-making and brand loyalty. For example, a fashion retailer may discover that Apathetic Obedient customers value the emotional comfort and confidence that comes with wearing reliable, timeless pieces. Energetic Obedient customers, on the other hand, may seek out the emotional thrill and self-expression associated with trendy, bold fashion choices. By understanding these emotional drivers, the retailer can build a brand identity that speaks to the diverse emotional needs of its customers, creating a strong emotional connection that transcends functional attributes.
  2. Crafting an Emotionally Resonant Brand Narrative: Insights gained from customer segments can inform the development of an emotionally compelling brand narrative. A home decor brand, for instance, may learn that Gruffly Domineering customers value the emotional satisfaction of creating a personalized, well-crafted living space, while Simply Desperate customers seek the emotional relief and comfort of a welcoming home environment. By weaving these emotional themes into its brand narrative, the home decor brand can position itself as a trusted partner in helping customers create spaces that evoke desired emotions and reflect their unique personalities. This emotionally resonant brand narrative can forge deep, meaningful connections with customers across all segments.
  3. Developing Emotionally Engaging Brand Experiences: By understanding the emotional needs and preferences of each customer segment, brands can design emotionally engaging experiences that strengthen brand affinity. A travel company, for example, may discover that Diplomatically Domineering customers value the emotional fulfillment of immersive, culturally rich travel experiences, while Desperate Jesters seek the emotional joy and excitement of unexpected, off-the-beaten-path adventures. By tailoring its brand experiences to cater to these emotional desires, the travel company can create memorable, emotionally charged moments that deepen customer connections and loyalty. These emotionally engaging experiences can become a defining feature of the brand, setting it apart from competitors and creating a strong emotional bond with customers across segments.
  4. Delivering Emotionally Supportive Customer Service: Insights into the emotional needs of customer segments can guide the development of emotionally supportive customer service strategies. A healthcare brand, for instance, may learn that Apathetic Obedient customers value the emotional reassurance and trust that comes with consistent, reliable support, while Energetic Obedient customers appreciate the emotional empowerment and motivation provided by proactive, personalized guidance. By training its customer service team to deliver emotionally attuned support that addresses the specific needs of each segment, the healthcare brand can build a reputation for compassionate, emotionally intelligent care. This emotionally supportive approach can foster deep, long-lasting customer relationships and contribute to a strong emotional brand identity.
  5. Fostering Emotional Brand Communities: By understanding the emotional drivers and needs of customer segments, brands can foster emotionally connected brand communities. A fitness brand, for example, may discover that Energetic Obedient customers value the emotional camaraderie and motivation found in a supportive fitness community, while Desperate Jesters seek the emotional boost and lightheartedness of a fun, inclusive workout environment. By creating online and offline spaces where customers can connect, share experiences, and support one another, the fitness brand can cultivate a strong sense of emotional belonging and loyalty. These emotionally connected brand communities can become powerful advocates for the brand, spreading positive word-of-mouth and deepening emotional ties with customers across all segments.

By leveraging Tolstoy’s customer segmentation approach to understand the emotional needs and motivations of their diverse customer base, brands can build a powerful emotional brand identity that resonates with all segments.

Marketing and Communication

Effective marketing and communication are essential for brands to reach, engage, and persuade their target audience. By leveraging Tolstoy’s customer segmentation approach, brands can develop highly targeted and personalized marketing strategies that resonate with each customer segment, ultimately driving better results and stronger customer connections.

  1. Tailored Messaging and Content: Insights gained from customer segments can inform the development of tailored messaging and content that speaks directly to the needs, preferences, and emotional drivers of each group. For example, a technology brand may learn that Apathetic Obedient customers value clear, concise information about product features and benefits, while Energetic Obedient customers respond well to inspirational, aspirational content that showcases how the brand’s products can enhance their lives. By crafting segment-specific messaging and content, the brand can improve the relevance and impact of its marketing efforts, increasing engagement and conversions across all customer categories.
  2. Personalized Channel Selection: Understanding the communication preferences and behaviours of each customer segment can guide brands in selecting the most effective marketing channels for each group. A financial services company, for instance, may discover that Diplomatically Domineering customers prefer in-depth, educational content delivered through thought leadership articles and webinars, while Desperate Jesters respond well to humorous, bite-sized social media content. By aligning its channel strategy with the preferences of each segment, the company can optimize its marketing spend and improve the reach and impact of its communications.
  3. Targeted Ad Campaigns: Customer segmentation insights can inform the development of targeted ad campaigns that are tailored to the specific interests, needs, and behaviours of each group. A fashion retailer, for example, may create distinct ad campaigns for Apathetic Obedient customers who value timeless, classic styles and for Energetic Obedient customers who are drawn to bold, trendy looks. By leveraging data-driven targeting capabilities, the retailer can ensure that each ad campaign reaches the right audience with the right message, improving ad relevance and performance.
  4. Personalized Email Marketing: By segmenting its email subscriber list based on Tolstoy’s customer categories, brands can deliver highly personalized email marketing campaigns that resonate with each group. A health and wellness brand, for instance, may send Apathetic Obedient customers educational content focused on building simple, healthy habits, while sending Energetic Obedient customers motivational content and exclusive offers for the latest fitness trends. By tailoring its email content and offers to the specific needs and interests of each segment, the brand can improve email engagement, click-through rates, and conversions.
  5. Segment-Specific Landing Pages and Website Experiences: Insights into the preferences and behaviours of customer segments can guide the development of segment-specific landing pages and website experiences. A travel company, for example, may create distinct landing pages for Gruffly Domineering customers who value luxury, all-inclusive packages and for Simply Desperate customers who are seeking last-minute, budget-friendly deals. By designing web experiences that cater to the specific needs and emotional drivers of each segment, the company can improve website engagement, conversion rates, and customer satisfaction.
  6. Personalized Product Recommendations and Offers: By analyzing the purchase histories and behaviours of customer segments, brands can deliver personalized product recommendations and offers that are tailored to the specific interests and needs of each group. An e-commerce retailer, for instance, may recommend premium, high-quality products to Diplomatically Domineering customers who value craftsmanship and durability, while offering value-focused bundles and deals to Apathetic Obedient customers who prioritize affordability. By providing segment-specific recommendations and offers, the retailer can improve customer engagement, average order value, and lifetime value.

By providing relevant, emotionally attuned communications and experiences, brands can build stronger, more meaningful connections with customers across all segments, fostering long-term loyalty and advocacy. Ultimately, by putting customer segmentation insights at the heart of their marketing and communication strategies, brands can differentiate themselves in the market and drive sustainable growth and success.

Customer Loyalty and Retention

Customer loyalty and retention are critical for brands to achieve long-term growth and profitability. By leveraging Tolstoy’s customer segmentation approach, brands can develop targeted strategies to nurture loyalty and minimize churn for each customer segment, ultimately driving higher customer lifetime value and brand advocacy.

  1. Segment-Specific Loyalty Programs: Insights gained from customer segments can inform the development of tailored loyalty programs that cater to the specific needs, preferences, and motivations of each group. For example, a retail brand may create a tiered loyalty program that rewards Apathetic Obedient customers for their consistent, long-term purchases, while offering Energetic Obedient customers exclusive access to new product launches and VIP events. By designing loyalty programs that align with the unique values and behaviours of each segment, brands can foster a deeper sense of appreciation and commitment among their customers.
  2. Personalized Retention Offers and Incentives: By analyzing the purchase histories and behaviours of customer segments, brands can identify at-risk customers and develop personalized retention offers and incentives to prevent churn. A subscription-based software company, for instance, may proactively reach out to Gruffly Domineering customers who have not engaged with the product recently, offering them a complimentary coaching session or a temporary upgrade to a premium feature set. By providing segment-specific retention offers that address the unique needs and pain points of each group, brands can improve customer retention rates and build long-term loyalty.
  3. Emotionally Engaging Loyalty Experiences: Understanding the emotional drivers and preferences of customer segments can guide brands in creating emotionally engaging loyalty experiences that strengthen customer bonds. A hospitality brand, for example, may surprise and delight its Simply Desperate customers who are celebrating special occasions with personalized gestures, such as room upgrades or complimentary champagne. By delivering emotionally resonant experiences that cater to the specific needs and desires of each segment, brands can create memorable moments that deepen customer loyalty and encourage repeat business.
  4. Segment-Specific Communication and Support: Insights into the communication preferences and needs of customer segments can inform the development of tailored communication and support strategies. A financial services company, for instance, may provide its Diplomatically Domineering customers with dedicated relationship managers who offer personalized financial advice and proactive account monitoring. By adapting its communication and support approach to the specific needs and expectations of each segment, the company can improve customer satisfaction, build trust, and foster long-term loyalty.
  5. Segment-Specific Loyalty Partnerships and Rewards: Understanding the lifestyles, interests, and aspirations of customer segments can guide brands in forming strategic loyalty partnerships and developing segment-specific rewards. A fitness brand, for instance, may partner with a premium athleisure company to offer its Diplomatically Domineering customers exclusive discounts on high-end workout gear. By aligning its loyalty partnerships and rewards with the specific preferences and values of each segment, the brand can enhance the perceived value of its loyalty program and strengthen customer engagement and retention.

By demonstrating a deep understanding and appreciation of each segment’s unique needs and values, brands can foster a strong sense of loyalty and commitment among their customers, driving increased customer lifetime value and advocacy. Ultimately, by putting customer segmentation insights at the heart of their loyalty and retention efforts, brands can build a loyal, engaged customer base that fuels sustainable growth and success.

Brand Example 01— Starbucks

Starbucks, the global coffee chain, has long been known for its commitment to customer segmentation and personalization. By leveraging insights into the needs, preferences, and behaviours of its diverse customer base, Starbucks has developed targeted strategies that have helped it build a strong, emotionally resonant brand and foster deep customer loyalty.

Segmentation Strategy: Starbucks has segmented its customers into distinct groups based on their purchasing behaviours, preferences, and emotional drivers. For example, the company has identified segments such as:

  1. “Regulars” (Apathetic Obedient): These customers consistently visit Starbucks for their daily coffee fix, valuing the reliability and convenience of the brand.
  2. “Enthusiasts” (Energetic Obedient): These customers are passionate about coffee culture and actively engage with Starbucks’ products, events, and social media.
  3. “Vocal Advocates” (Diplomatically Domineering): These customers provide constructive feedback and suggestions to help Starbucks improve its offerings and customer experience.
  4. “On-the-Go” (Simply Desperate): These customers seek quick, efficient service and rely on Starbucks for their caffeine needs during busy days.

Personalized Experiences: Based on these segments, Starbucks has developed personalized experiences and offerings that cater to the specific needs and preferences of each group. For example:

  1. For “Regulars,” Starbucks offers a loyalty program that rewards frequent visits and purchases, encouraging long-term commitment to the brand.
  2. For “Enthusiasts,” Starbucks creates exclusive product launches, such as limited-edition coffee blends and merchandise, and hosts immersive coffee tasting events.
  3. For “Vocal Advocates,” Starbucks actively seeks out and incorporates customer feedback into its product development and store design processes, showing its commitment to customer-centricity.
  4. For “On-the-Go” customers, Starbucks has optimized its mobile ordering and payment system, allowing for seamless, efficient transactions.

Emotional Branding: Starbucks has also leveraged its segmentation insights to build a strong emotional brand connection with its customers. By understanding the emotional drivers and aspirations of each segment, Starbucks has crafted a brand narrative that emphasizes warmth, community, and human connection. From the inviting ambiance of its stores to the personalized touches in its customer interactions, Starbucks has created a brand experience that resonates emotionally with its diverse customer base.

Results: Through its customer segmentation and personalization strategies, Starbucks has achieved impressive results, including:

  1. High customer loyalty and repeat business, with its loyalty program boasting over 19 million active members in the U.S. alone.
  2. Strong brand advocacy, with customers actively sharing their positive experiences and recommending Starbucks to others.
  3. Continued growth and expansion, with Starbucks now operating over 30,000 stores worldwide.

By understanding and catering to the specific needs and preferences of its diverse customer base, Starbucks has built a brand that resonates deeply with its customers and has become a global icon in the coffee industry.

Brand Example 02 — Nike

Nike, the global sports apparel and footwear company, has long been recognized for its innovative approach to customer segmentation and personalization. By leveraging insights into the diverse needs, preferences, and motivations of its customer base, Nike has developed targeted strategies that have helped it build a powerful, emotionally resonant brand and cultivate a fiercely loyal following.

Segmentation Strategy: Nike has segmented its customers into distinct groups based on their athletic interests, lifestyle preferences, and emotional drivers. For example, the company has identified segments such as:

  1. “Weekend Warriors” (Apathetic Obedient): These customers consistently choose Nike for their casual athletic wear needs, valuing the brand’s reliability and style.
  2. “Fitness Enthusiasts” (Energetic Obedient): These customers are passionate about their fitness journeys and actively engage with Nike’s products, apps, and community events.
  3. “Performance-Driven Athletes” (Gruffly Domineering): These customers demand cutting-edge performance features and provide candid feedback to help Nike push the boundaries of innovation.
  4. “Sneakerheads” (Desperate Jesters): These customers are obsessed with Nike’s limited-edition and collectible sneaker releases, often going to great lengths to secure rare pairs.

Personalized Experiences: Based on these segments, Nike has developed personalized experiences and offerings that cater to the specific needs and preferences of each group. For example:

  1. For “Weekend Warriors,” Nike offers a wide range of stylish, comfortable apparel and footwear that seamlessly blend athletic functionality with casual fashion.
  2. For “Fitness Enthusiasts,” Nike provides personalized training plans, workout tracking, and access to exclusive fitness content through its Nike Training Club app.
  3. For “Performance-Driven Athletes,” Nike involves them in the product testing and feedback process, using their insights to drive innovation in its high-performance product lines.
  4. For “Sneakerheads,” Nike creates buzz and excitement around limited-edition sneaker drops, collaborating with artists, celebrities, and cultural influencers to create coveted, collectible designs.

Emotional Branding: Nike has also leveraged its segmentation insights to build a strong emotional brand connection with its customers. By understanding the emotional drivers and aspirations of each segment, Nike has crafted a brand narrative that emphasizes personal achievement, self-expression, and the power of sport to unite and inspire. From its iconic “Just Do It” slogan to its emotionally charged advertising campaigns, Nike has created a brand experience that resonates deeply with its diverse customer base.

Results: Through its customer segmentation and personalization strategies, Nike has achieved remarkable results, including:

  1. Unparalleled brand loyalty, with customers often displaying a lifelong commitment to the brand and its products.
  2. Massive global reach, with Nike products being worn and celebrated by athletes, celebrities, and everyday consumers across the world.
  3. Consistent growth and market leadership, with Nike remaining the world’s largest and most valuable sports apparel brand.

By understanding and catering to the specific needs, preferences, and emotional drivers of its diverse customer base, Nike has built a brand that inspires, empowers, and resonates with millions of people worldwide.

In conclusion, Tolstoy’s customer segmentation framework offers brands a powerful tool for understanding and catering to the diverse needs, preferences, and emotional drivers of their customers. By dividing customers into distinct segments based on their behaviors, motivations, and attitudes, brands can gain valuable insights that inform every aspect of their strategy, from value proposition and emotional branding to marketing, loyalty, and retention.

As the real-world examples of Starbucks and Nike demonstrate, applying Tolstoy’s segmentation approach can yield significant benefits, including increased customer loyalty, enhanced brand advocacy, and sustained growth and market leadership. By leveraging segmentation insights to develop personalized experiences, forge deep emotional connections, and continuously adapt to evolving customer needs, brands can build lasting, mutually beneficial relationships with their customers.

--

--